Annabelle Waterline Matte Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, Blackest Black, Intense Colours, Matte Finish, Easy-To-Apply, Long-Lasting 10H, Waterproof, Transfer-proof, Cruelty-Free, 1.2 g

Perfect affordable eyeliner that is lasts! Love it!
What a great eyeliner and so affordable! I discovered it here by another reviewer… and I’m so happy I did! Thank you! I have spent quite much in the past buying the Urban Decay Eyeliner until finding this one! As opposed to that one, I don’t need to wait for the it to dry it up and it stays for hours too, but the best part is that is $12 dollar cheaper! 😅 Also, is very easy to apply.. no mess whatsoever! I couldn’t be happier with my purchase and I highly recommend it.. you won’t be disappointed.. is totally worth the value! 🙂 “Chefmargie Sosa “ /You Tube Cooking Channel

Waterline winner!
Wish it went on a bit darker/ thicker but it is definitely waterproof longer than other “waterline” products.

Transfer proof is a bit misleading
I was looking for a liner to tightline my top lids. I searched ‘waterproof transfer proof tightliner’ I have used more than a few brands that have claims like this one.. ‘transfer/waterproof’ and have always had the same problem. I tightline my upper lid before mascara..apply mascara..blink a few times and the LINER IS NOW ON MY BOTTOM WATER LINE TOO!! 😖 *clenches fists*I have been searching oh so long for one that did not do this and I don’t think it’s possible at this point unless I go the permanent makeup route or drop 4 times what I did on this one and I’m not doing that. I was so anxious for this one to be the one. I don’t normally drop $15 on an eyeliner as this world is now a world of affordable cosmetics that actually rival high end brands and I’m here for alla that. But after wasting so much money trying to get a transfer proof liner already I figured maybe I had to spend a little more to get the results I wanted. It was not to be.I’ll probably never use it again as I have no use for this kind of liner beyond the purpose of tightlining. I use gel or liquid for my daily cat eye. This pencil could never be precise or sharp enough for that.This does have some positives. I immediately opened this and applied a definitive line on the back of my hand. I rubbed with my finger. I mean..created warmth rubbing. It did not move. I went about doing dishes and cooking dinner..washed my face and even applied hand lotion. That little line didn’t move. It is richly pigmented and easy to apply. It may be excellent if you wanted to tightline your bottom lid but it does travel from its original application site so I think it’s likely it will trend south after awhile and might possibly give you the ol sleepy racoon effect but I haven’t and don’t want to test this hypothesis. Maybe I can use it with a brush to smudge out my top liner. In summary.. where you apply this is not where it will stay. And don’t trust search results like I so naively did. It’s ok..not $15 ok. I got the same results with a $5 mechanical, thin, no sharpening needed eyeliner.NOT for tightlining your top lid only. 🙂

Eyeliner pencil
I love the way this goes on,it just glides on with no tugging. I also like the way it’ stays on even with watery eyes.

For some reason, while this product is great and does as it claims, it always seems to end up in the inner corners of my eyes and I have to go digging it out. Even the day/morning after application. Perhaps this is not a big deal but my concern is having the product, over time, accumulate in nasolacrimal duct. I want to wipe it off at the end of the day, not have it find a home somewhere in my body or bloodstream.

Works well, until you have to sharpen. I thought it was great price, but if you can only use a handful of times, it’s a waste.I tired to sharpen with a few different sharpeners, doesn’t work.